Grace Vaccaro, Staff Writer
On November 8th, the new Broadway musical “Wanted” debuted at the James Earl Jones Theater. This musical is written by Angelica Chéri, an NAACP Award–nominated playwright, musical theatre bookwriter and lyricist, screenwriter, and poet. She was named by Variety as one of Broadway’s Top Ten Stars to Watch in 2025.
Her new musical, Wanted (formerly titled Gun & Powder), is an R&B Western musical inspired by the true 1893 story of Mary and Martha Clarke. Chéri originally thought of the idea in her NYU Graduate Musical Theatre Writing Program. Mary and Martha Clarke are the great-great-aunts of Chéri, who grew up hearing stories about their lives.
Gun & Powder went through many stages of workshops and was selected for the 2017 SigWorks Musical Theater Lab at the Signature Theatre in Arlington. Gun & Powder made its sold-out debut in 2020 in the Signature Theatre. It received a New York Times critic pick and had generally positive reviews. It was changed again in 2024 and performed at Paper Mill Playhouse. Finally, in 2025, it was announced to debut on Broadway under the new name: Wanted.
The play takes place in Texas, thirty years after the Emancipation Proclamation was passed. Mary and Martha Clarke lived in the 1890s, passing as white. They were outlaws, committing multiple unspecified crimes. Chéri had heard from family members that included tales of a train robbery, a bank heist, and encounters on the road.
The show begins with Mary and Martha as sharecroppers. They decide that to find better work and lives, they will need to pass as white. Once they leave the plantation, they head to a bank where they make their first robbery. Afterwards, they are on the run.
The songs from the musical have received praise for their human-like qualities. The genres shift between R&B, rootsy country, and gospel-style melisma. By far, the standout song of the production is “The Way I Am.” It follows Mary as she sings into a mirror, the ghosts of her ancestors crowding around her. The song tackles the struggle the sisters have with what it means to live their lives passing as white instead of black.
Solea Pfeiffer and Liisi LaFontaine, who play the sisters, are praised for their vocal performance. Pfeiffer had formerly performed in Hamilton as Eliza Schuyler. LaFontaine is best known for her roles in the stage productions of Dreamgirls and Moulin Rouge!
Wanted breaks boundaries and awards. Chéri became the first Black woman to write both the book and lyrics of a wholly original Broadway musical in nearly 50 years. Chéri shared how the James Earl Jones Theater is meaningful to her and her journey in the writing world. Before her father passed away in 2024, he would give her words of encouragement by quoting the characters Mufasa and Darth Vader. Both of these characters were voiced by James Earl Jones.
With Wanted’s long journey to the stage, it is time to celebrate such an emotional and important piece of work. If this musical seems like one you would enjoy, make sure to get your own tickets to see it for yourself.
Leave a Reply